ICPR Abstracts: Session 22
Session 22: Daytime Posters
Conceptual and Measurement Issues
in Attachment Research
22.1
Processes of Adult Attachment Formation:
A Preliminary Test of a Theoretical Model
Debra Zeifman, Francesco Del Vecchio,
Inna Shchuchinsky, and Cindy Hazan
Cornell University
Adult attachment research typically presumes that
romantic relationships are, by definition, attachment
relationships. However, findings from our previous work
indicate that such a presumption is not always warranted.
We conducted a series of studies designed to evaluate the
hypothesis that a primary difference between attached and
nonattached status is the effect of a partner's presence and
absence on overall arousal. A variety of methods were
employed, including observational, physiological, and self-
report. The results provide insights into the processes by
which adult attachment bonds are formed and suggest
criteria for classifying individuals as attached or not.
22.2
Attachment Styles and Internal Working
Models of Self
Eva C. Klohnen and Oliver P. John
University of California, Berkeley
Internal working models underlie attachment patterns in
relationships yet little work has examined how internal
models differ among attachment styles. Experts assessed
the prototypicality of a comprehensive list of adjectives for
each attachment style. Based on these theory-derived
prototypes, we constructed eight preliminary scales:
secure, positive other, preoccupied, negative self, fearful
avoidant, negative other, dismissive avoidant, and positive
self. In a large sample we tested--and found evidence for--
the convergent and discriminant validity of the expert
prototypes, and for the preliminary scales and their
circumplex structure. We present a revised set of eight 10-
item scales to measure internal working models.
22.3
Working Models of Self and Others:
Structure and Clarity
Katherine Kerr and Nancy Collins
State University of New York at Buffalo
The purpose of this study was to examine attachment style
differences in the clarity of working models of self and
others. Participants were asked to make judgments about
themselves and the typical romantic partner using a series
of bipolar scales (e.g. lovable-unlovable, accepting-
rejecting). Half of the items were attachment-relevant and
half were attachment-irrelevant. Stimuli were presented
on a computer so that response latencies could be
recorded. Results provide preliminary evidence that
people differ not only with regard to the content of their
working models of attachment, but also in terms of the
structure, coherence, and accessibility of these models.
22.4
Exploration of an Ambivalent Cluster Within the
Preoccupied and Fearful Attachment Patterns
James M. Fuendeling
Michigan State University
The validity of an ambivalent/approach-avoidant pattern of
adult attachment lying on the border of Bartholomew's
Preoccupied and Fearful-avoidant styles was examined
using Brennan and Shaver's Dimensions of Adult
Attachments. 180 subjects scoring as Preoccupied or
Fearful-avoidant on the Relationship Scales Questionnaire
were separated into three groups based on a cluster
analysis with the seven Dimensions of Adult Attachment
as grouping variables. The resulting groups' mean scores
on the dimensions of attachment suggest that these groups
correspond to theoretically typical Fearful avoidant types,
Preoccupied types, and to a third group showing high
anxiety and a combination of enmeshing and avoidant
tendencies.
22.5
Development of a New Multi-Item Measure of Adult
Romantic Attachment: A Preliminary Report
Kelly A. Brennan, University of Texas,
Phillip R. Shaver, and Catherine L. Clark
University of California, Davis
Adult romantic attachment has made many substantive
strides since the field's inception in 1987. Without an
agreed-upon, common metric for researchers to use,
however, the field will quickly splinter. Toward that end,
we conducted a survey developing new self-report
attachment-style measures by combining and comparing
existing self-report attachment measures. We used factor
and cluster-analytic techniques to determine the number of
basic-level dimensions and confirm the existence of a
higher-order, two- dimensional structure. We then
conducted a cluster-analysis with the two higher-order
factors to produce an optimal number of clusters and
tested the viability of those clusters with regard to
subjects' self-classifications.
Stress and Coping
22.6
Personal Relationships and Social Change
Robin Goodwin
Bristol University
Despite the interest in social transitions amongst social
scientists, there has been little systematic analysis of the
impact of rapid change on personal relationships. In this
study I propose two related models that address 1) rapid
and unexpected socio- political changes and 2) planned
social transitions. These models broadly predict that
cultural, within group and individual-level factors predict
the appraisal of change, and that the stress that arises from
negative appraisals (threat or challenge) can then be
mediated by social support. Negative appraisals plus a
lack of appropriate support is predicted to impact
negatively on the marital relationship. Data to assess these
models is provided from two sets of studies in three
Eastern Europe countries and in Hong Kong.
22.7
Relationships, Personal Factors and Work Conditions
As Sources Of Stress For Fire Department Employees:
An Analysis of Employee and Spouse Perspectives
Mark Attridge, Joni Lapp, and Ruth Jackson
United HealthCare Corporation, Golden Valley, MN
This survey identifies and prioritizes the aspects of work
and personal life that are perceived as stressful to the
employees of a city fire department, both from the
perspective of the employee and from that of the
employee's romantic partner. A total of 22 of 33 areas
were rated by a third or more of all employees as stressful,
including maintaining relationships with a romantic
partner, and maintaining relationships with children.
Respondents tended to rate issues as more stressful for
others than for themselves. Few significant differences
were found between responses of romantic partners and
employees.
22.8
Motivational Support and Motivational Hindrance
Have Opposing Influences on Optimism
Philip Ituarte
University of Pittsburgh
Little is known about the effects of the social environment
on optimism, which is recognized as an important coping
resource. This research proposed that two types of social
interactions, motivational support and motivational
hindrance, would have opposing influences on optimism.
Study participants were graduating college seniors (n230)
who shared a common goal. The receipt of motivational
support was associated with more optimism, and
hindrance was associated with less optimism in cross-
sectional analyses. Only motivational hindrance was
predictive of optimism in longitudinal analyses.
Compared to friends, motivational support provided by
family members was especially influential on optimism in
this sample. Thus, the experience of optimism is
responsive to social interactions.
22.9
Attachment Style Differences in Supportive Exchanges
Brooke Feeney and Nancy Collins
State University of New York at Buffalo
This study examined attachment style differences in
support-seeking and support-giving processes in dating
couples. Participants were 104 couples who participated
in a video-taped, laboratory interaction. During the
interaction, one couple member was assigned the role of
"stress-discloser" and the other the role of "support-
provider." Couples completed questionnaires to assess
their perceptions of the interaction. In addition, objective
ratings of support-seeking (e.g., level of emotional
disclosure) and support-giving (e.g., eye contact,
emotional support) behaviors were coded from the
videotapes. Results indicated that attachment style was an
important predictor of partners' perceptions of the
interaction as well as the more objective behaviors coded
by independent observers. Implications for attachment
theory and social support theory will be discussed.
22.10
Personality and Coping Among Married Couples
Melady Preece, Tess O'Brien, Anita DeLongis, and
Jennifer Campbell, University of British Columbia
This study examined personality and coping in an
interactional context. Married couples reported marital
stressors and coping efforts each day for 14 consecutive
days. Personality was assessed with the NEO Five-factor
Inventory (Costa & McCrae, 1989). Problem- and
emotion-focused coping were measured with the Ways of
Coping scale (Folkman, Lazarus, Dunkel- Schetter,
DeLongis, & Gruen, 1986), and relationship-focused
coping was measured with the Empathic Responding scale
(O'Brien & DeLongis, in press-a & b). Results showed
that ways of coping with marital stressors were predicted
by the individual's personality, with additional variance in
coping accounted for by the personality of the spouse.
22.11
Agency, Unmitigated Agency and Adjustment to
Prostate Cancer:The Role of Emotional Expressiveness
Vicki S. Helgeson and Stephen J. Lepore
Carnegie Mellon University
The goal of the study was to examine the relations of
agency (focus on self) and unmitigated agency (focus on
self to the exclusion of others) to adjustment to prostate
cancer, and to determine the extent to which emotional
expressiveness accounted for the associations. Men
recently diagnosed with prostate cancer (n=167) were
returned questionnaires that assessed these constructs as
well as a wide array of adjustment indices. Agency was
related to good adjustment, and unmitigated agency was
related to poor adjustment across the indices. Difficulty
with emotional expression accounted for the relation of
unmitigated agency to poor adjustment.
22.12
Response to Breast Cancer: Analysis of Couple
Interactive Coping
Gretchen M. Zunkel
University of Washington
The diagnosis of breast cancer, now affecting one in eight
women, is currently a dominant concern of the women's
health agenda. Research studies are just beginning to
examine the relational aspects of coping, adaptation, and
healing which may result in immune system enhancement
for cancer patients (Kiecolt-Glaser, Malarkey, Chee,
Newton, Cacioppo, Mao & Glaser, 1993). This line of
research will extend current research on interactive coping
and elicitation of support behaviors from partners (Barbee,
1990; Cutrona, Suhr, MacFarlane, 1990). This qualitative
study will examine transcripts from women with a
diagnosis of breast cancer and their male partners as well
as couple interviews for evidence of factors in the dyadic
relationship that reflect the interactive coping of the
couple.
22.13
Family Bereavement: A Study of Coping in Couples
I. Dijkstra, M. Stroebe, J. van den Bout,
H. Schut, & W. Stroebe
Utrecht University
An ongoing project is described which studies grieving in
a family context. In the past, too little recognition has been
given to the fact that people do not grieve in complete
isolation, but interact with others, some of whom are also
grieving. This longitudinal study focuses on couples who
have lost a child. It is assumed that the interdependence of
coping processes within a marital dyad may result not only
in mutual facilitation or interference in the grieving
process itself, but may also be associated with changes in
the marital relationship. The results of two small-scale
studies are presented.
Friendship -- Developmental, Cultural,
and Individual Difference Factors
22.14
A Cross-Sectional Survey of Adult Friendships
in the U.S.
Roger Baumgarte, Winthrop University
Elisabeth Gareis, Baruch College/CUNY
Developmental aspects of friendship are examined in
survey data gathered on 500 adults of varying ages in the
U.S. With increasing age, these respondents report a
decline in some of the negative aspects of their friendships
such as criticism, conflict, jealousy and deception.
However, corresponding declines were also found in some
positive aspects of these relationships, such as asking for,
and offering instrumental aid. In addition, older friends
report less self-monitoring and a lower tendency to imitate
their friends. These data are interpreted to suggest that,
with age, adults become more independent and
autonomous in their friendships.
22.15
What's Your Friend Like? Age and Ethnic Generality
of the Big Five Personality Dimensions
Christine Storm and Thomas Storm
Mount Allison University
This study examined the spontaneous descriptions of peers
by 120 New Zealand children aged 8, 10, and 12 years,
from two ethnic groups: pakeha children from an Auckland
suburb and Maori children from a rural North Island
community. Children were asked to tell an adult
interviewer what each of five target peers were like. Two
targets were persons named as friends, three were chosen
at random from the same class, and two were "people you
don't like". The adequacy of the Big Five personality
dimensions and age, gender, and ethnic differences in their
differentiation and salience are examined.
22.16
The Influence of Age and Cultural Norms on
Inter- and Intra-cultural Adolescent
Friendship Development
Arlene R. Lundquist
Creighton University
The overall purpose of the research was to: (1) identify
factors (norms) which influence the development of
adolescent friendship, (2) compare the relative influences
of these factors (norms) on friendships maintained during
early and late adolescence, and (3) investigate the
proposed relationship between the norms of adolescent
friendship and potential stumbling blocks to formation of
cross-cultural friendships in adolescence. Norms of
adolescent friendship are evaluated via 5 measures; self-
perception/self- esteem, qualities expected of friends,
expressed and wanted inclusion behavior, friendship
attitudes vs. behavior consistency, and nonverbal intimacy
behavior is observed in a 30 minute semi- structured
interview with pairs of friends.
22.17
A Cross-Cultural Exploration of the Stability of
Children's Friendships and the Predictors of their
Continuation
Barry H. Schneider, Ada Fonzi, Franca Tani, and
Giovanna Tomada, University of Toronto
The purpose of this study was to explore cross-cultural
differences in children's perceptions of friendship quality
and in the predictors of the subsequent continuation or
termination of their relationships. Participants were third-
and fourth-grade children in Florence, Italy, and Toronto,
Canada. A total of 184 dyads of children who indicated
that they were friends near the beginning of school year
completed questionnaires regarding the quality of their
relationships. Compared to Canadians, a higher
proportion of Italian friendships remained intact through
the end of the school year. Positive aspects of relationship
quality at the first data collection point were associated
with future friendship status, but earlier conflict within the
dyad was unrelated to the continuation of friendship.
Contrary to expectations, the levels of conflict reported by
the children were lower in the Italian sample than in
Canada. Few gender differences were found in the
predictors of friendship continuation.
22.18
Psychological Meaning of Loneliness in Adolescence
Maria Montero y Lopez Lena
National Autonomous University of Mexico
School of Psychology
The concept of loneliness has been traditionally associated
with a subjective and unpleasant experience, as well as a
response to a deficit in interpersonal relationships.
Socialization practices in Mexico promote the value of
social affiliation or gregarism (Diaz- Guerrero,
1972/1986). The main question of this exploratory study
was whether a group of adolescents could identify the
experience of loneliness and how they would define it.
The psychological meaning of loneliness was
measured by a Natural Semantic Network technique
(Figueroa, 1980, 1981). This criteria provides a) the
denotative and connotative meaning of loneliness, b) the
amount of words used to define loneliness, and c) the
semantic distance between concepts.
Results showed that both males and females in
the three age groups measured associated loneliness with
negative concepts. Younger adolescents appear to
experience loneliness as more unpleasant, while older age
groups mentioned some positive concepts. Men presented
a more compact density network (c) than women, whereas
women used more concepts to define loneliness than men
(b).
Following these results, we conceptualize
loneliness as a type of stressor that can have both a
negative outcome, when experienced as a social or
emotional deficit, and a positive outcome, when
experienced as an opportunity for growing.
22.19
The Effects of Gender Related Personality
Characteristics on Affection Giving Behaviors in
Male/Female Relationships
Ann Marie West
Claremont Graduate School
The relationship between gender-related personality
characteristics and the degree of affection giving in
relationships was examined. It was hypothesized that
positive and negative femininity would positively predict
affection giving. It was also predicted that positive and
negative masculinity would negatively predict affection
giving. Further, it was expected that partners would give
reciprocal amounts of affection to each other. A regression
analysis revealed that positive femininity was a significant
positive predictor of affection giving behaviors while
negative femininity was a significant negative predictor of
affection giving behaviors. Finally, male and female
affection giving behaviors were significant positive
predictors of each other.
22.20
Power and the Quality of Same-Sex Friendships
Letitia Anne Peplau and Rose Veniegas
University of California, Los Angeles
Why are some friendships more rewarding and satisfying
than others? The balance of power may offer one
explanation. Currently, little is known about dominance
in friendship, in part because researchers often assume
that friendships are inherently egalitarian. The current
study compared the quality of same-sex friendships judged
to be equal versus unequal in power. As predicted, both
men and women evaluated equal-power friendships more
favorably on all measures of quality. Equal-power
friendships were described as more satisfying, close,
intimate, and rewarding than unequal relationships.
Conflict in Marriage and the Family
22.21
Conflict in Parental Support Networks:
Comparisons of Mothers and Fathers
Anupama A. Joshi and Gail F. Melson
Purdue University
This study examined conflict in parental support networks
of mothers and fathers of preschool children. It was
hypothesized that parents would experience more conflict
in closer and longer relationships. Difference between
mothers and fathers in the level of perceived conflict was
not expected. A mediation hypothesis was also tested
predicting a mediating influence of family conflict on the
relationship between conflict in the network and
aggravations perceived in parenting. Fifty-three couples
participated in this study. Data were collected through
home interviews. Results confirmed some of the
hypotheses. Mothers and fathers did not differ in the
amount of perceived conflict in their parental support
networks. The mediation hypothesis was confirmed for
mothers but not for fathers. Network correlates of conflict
were different for mothers and fathers. However, for both
mothers and fathers, perceived conflict was higher with
relatives than with friends and service providers. It is
suggested that future research should closely examine the
role of conflict in specific relationships and the underlying
processes for differences in mothers and fathers.
22.22
Changes in Conflict Behaviors Over Time:
An Exploration with African American
and White Couples
Susan E. Crohan
Wheelock College
Changes in conflict behaviors (constructive, destructive
and avoidant) were explored in a longitudinal study of the
first years of marriage with 133 African American and 149
White couples. Results using self-report data showed that
spouses reported more destructive and avoidant conflict
behaviors and fewer constructive conflict behaviors in year
3 than year 1. There were also main effects for gender and
race. Husbands were more likely than wives to engage in
constructive conflict and to leave the scene of conflict and
less likely than wives to engage in destructive conflict.
African Americans were more likely than Whites to
engage in constructive conflict and avoidance.
22.23
Sibling Differences in Communication Patterns During
Sibling Conflict:The Influence of Parental Favouritism
Grania Sheehan, Judith Feeney, Patricia Noller
and Candi Peterson, University of Queensland
The theory of nonshared environment and the possible
compounding nature of nonshared relationship experiences
in the family will be examined. In particular the link
between adolescents' experiences of parental favouritism
and differences in siblings communication patterns during
sibling conflict. One hundred and ninety eight adolescent
twin sibling pairs were involved in the study. The study
used two forms of measurement: 1) Self-report
standardised scales measuring parental favouritism and
sibling communication conflict patterns and 2)
Observational measures of videotaped sibling interaction,
both insider and outsider. The implications of the findings
for the theory of nonshared environment, and for the
transmission and continuity of communication patterns
across familial relationships will be discussed.
Parent-Child Relationships
22.24
Parents' Monitoring of Children's Daily Experiences:
Patterns Within and Between Families
Ann C. Crouter, Heather Helms-Erikson,
and Kimberly Updegraff,
Pennsylvania State University
Between and within family differences in parental
monitoring were explored by (1) comparing mothers' and
fathers' monitoring of older and younger siblings, and (2)
by examining sex, temperament and parental work
conditions as correlates of monitoring. Personal qualities,
family relationships, work conditions, and monitoring (i.e.,
parents' knowledge about children's daily experiences)
were assessed in home and telephone interviews with
dual-earner parents and their two school-aged children (n
100 families). Monitoring varied as a function of the sex
composition of the sibling dyad, children's temperaments,
and sex of parent. Fathers monitored more effectively
when their wives worked more hours.
22.25
Control Processes in Parent-Child Relationships in
Middle Childhood
Kathryn A. Kerns, Patricia L. Tomich,
Jeffery E. Aspelmeier and Chandra M. Graybill
Kent State University
Although monitoring is often treated as a characteristic of
parents, it is an attribute of parent-child dyads, with both
parents and children contribution. The present study
examined monitoring in mother-child and father-child
dyads, including an assessment of the child's contribution
to the monitoring process. Third and sixth grade children
and their parents participated in a phone monitoring
interview, parents reported children's willingness to check
in with parents, and teachers reported children's behavior
at school. Mothers were more successful at monitoring
than were fathers. Children who were more responsible
about checking in with parents were described more
positively by teachers.
22.26
Age-related Differences in Correlates of Parent-child
Interdependence During Preadolescence and
Adolescence
Daniel J. Repinski, State University of New York
W. Andrew Collins, University of Minnesota
Behavioral interdependence is a fundamental property of
relationships, but correlations between interdependence
and other properties of relationships may vary as dyads
adapt to individual changes. To test this prediction,
children in grades 5, 7, 9, and 11 and their parents
completed a child/adolescent version of the Relationships
Closeness Inventory and measures of emotional tone and
subjective closeness. Interdependence, emotional tone,
and subjective closeness were only moderately
intercorrelated. Both degree of intercorrelation and mean
scores were inverted U-shaped functions of grade level.
Across grades, intercorrelations among relationship
properties were higher for fathers than for mothers.
Implications for research on relationship change are
discussed.
22.27
The Positive Effects of Children's Disabilities and
Medical Challenges on Fathers' Generativity: A
Grounded Theory Approach
Kathy Froerer, Alan J. Hawkins,
Jenifer Jarvis, and David C. Dollahite
Brigham Young University
This qualitative, grounded theory study examines how
fathers' relationships with their disabled children or
children with other medical challenges can assist men in
the development of generativity. One of the themes from
our data was that fathers of children with medical
challenges are willing to go to great lengths to meet the
needs of their children. Another theme was that fathers
watching children suffer with medical challenges often
develop greater compassion and patience. Thus, a concept
that emerged is that children with disabilities or medical
challenges have tremendous needs for care that call for
fathers to develop generativity.
22.28 [withdrawn]
22.29
Leaving-Home Transition in Israel:
Changes in Parents-Adolescents Relationships
and Adaptation to Military Service
Ofra Mayseless
University of Haifa
Physical separation from one's parents into college was
found to be associated with positive changes in the
parents-adolescent relationship. The reported study
extended previous findings by studying the effects of
physical separation from one's parents in the Israeli
culture, when the timing of home-leaving is based on the
youngsters' age (18), and is into a mandatory military
service. A group of 143 young men participated in the
study and filled out questionnaires regarding their
relationships with their parents and their adjustment and
coping at two points in time: three months before
conscription and three months later. Relationships with
parents were reported to improve. In addition, base line
levels of relationships with parents, and changes in them
significantly contributed to an increase in feelings of
control and adjustment.
22.30
Mothering and Fathering: Factors Influencing
Perceived Role Changes Following Divorce
Mary S. Marczak, Lucinda M. Steenbergen,
Donna J. Peterson, and Donna Hendrickson
Christensen, University of Arizona
After marital disruption, parents must redefine parental
roles or assume new roles that may not fall within
stereotyped sex-role standards. Interviews with 33
divorced mothers and fathers revealed three categories of
perceived parental role changes: role gain, role loss, and
role constancy. Through content analyses, this study will
examine factors which may influence the meaning parents
place on these changing parental roles following divorce.
An initial analysis indicates that gender and custody status
seem less influential than gender role attitudes regarding
mothering and fathering. Other factors to be examined
will include visitation with children and coparenting.
22.31
Post-Divorce Parental Communication Modes
Donna Hendrickson Christensen, Donna J. Peterson,
Mary S. Marczak, and Lucinda M. Steenbergen
University of Arizona
The purpose of this study is to examine the modes of
communication that divorced parents use when interacting
about their children. Past studies of divorced parities'
communication have primarily focused on verbal
communication, extending on models of successful marital
communication. This may not be a relevant standard for
divorced partners. It is possible that divorced parents,
who may not be effective verbal communicators, have
learned to employ alternative modes when interacting on
parenting issues. Interview data from 33 divorced parents
will be used to answer this question. Initial analyses show
that divorced parents describe using a variety of
communication modes, including using fax machines,
letters, and mutual friends as intermediators.
22.32
Stepparents' Affinity-Seeking and
Affinity-Maintaining Strategies With Stepchildren
Lawrence Ganong, Marilyn Coleman,
Mark Fine, and Patricia Martin
University of Missouri-Columbia
The purpose of this study was to explore the strategies that
stepparents use to develop and to maintain affinity with
their stepchildren. Specific research questions addressed
include: (a) What do stepparents do to get their adolescent
stepchildren to like them?; (b) What do parents do to help
their spouses and children develop good relationships
together?; and (c) What do adolescent stepchildren do to
develop (and maintain) affinity with their stepparents?
Data were collected via questionnaires and with
stepparents, their spouses, and a stepchild between ages
10-18. Stepfamilies were recruited via snowball sampling
techniques and local media advertisements.
22.33
"When Daddy Comes Home":
A Narrative Study of Generative Fathering and
Relationship Work
Sean E. Brotherson, Oregon State University
Alan J. Hawkins and David C. Dollahite, Brigham
Young University
In-depth interviews were conducted with 25 fathers of
disabled children concerning their caregiving experiences
with their children. This research focused on investigating
a model of generative fathering through examining
narrative accounts that reflect patterns in fathering
behavior. Coding and analysis of the fathers' narratives
demonstrated broad and solid support for the concept of
relationship work outlined in the generative fathering
model. Relationship work involves the responsibilities to
connect with and communicate with children for their
benefit and well- being. This means facilitating
interpersonal attachments and encouraging understanding
between fathers and children.
Mark Baldwin - <baldwin@uwinnipeg.ca>,
Alison Wiigs - <wiigs@ucalgary.ca>