ICPR Abstracts: Session 11
Session 11: Evening Posters
Attachment in the Family
11.1
Attachment Relationships and Family Style:
A Cultural Perspective
M. Ali Mazaheri-Tehrani and David Jones
Birkbeck College
Patterns of attachment relationship and family style have
been assessed in a sample of 52 nuclear intact families in
Iran. Questionnaire data were obtained from both parents.
A preschool child in each family completed the SAT and
the Family Drawings Test, and an infant together with the
mother participated in the Ainsworth's Strange Situation.
In addition behavioral ratings were obtained for both
children. Cultural comparisons suggest variations in the
scores on individual measures relative to those reported
for western samples; e.g. proportion of infants in different
patterns of attachment. Intrafamilial patterns of
attachment will also be discussed.
11.2
The Relationship Between Adults' Attachment
Hierarchies and Their Attachment Patterns
Shanna J. Trinke and Kim Bartholomew
Simon Fraser University
The present study examined the association between
individuals' attachment patterns and the characteristics of
their attachment networks (the number and rank ordering
of their attachment figures). We used the recently
developed Attachment Network Questionnaire (ANQ;
Trinke & Bartholomew, 1995) to measure the multiple
attachment relationships of 223 university undergraduates.
Self-reported attachment security with specific figures was
correlated with ranking those figures more highly overall
on various attachment components. Interview attachment
ratings predicted the number of people listed on the ANQ
and the number of attachments individuals were judged to
have. Differences in the results obtained by the two
methods of assessing attachment patterns are discussed.
11.3
Maternal Separation Anxiety: Its Relationship to
Developmental Separation Experiences, Marital
Satisfaction, Divorce, and Self- Reported Anxiety
Elisa Velasquez, University of New Orleans
Maria Montero y Lopez Lena, National Autonomous
University of Mexico
Deborah Mahan, University of New Orleans
Maternal separation anxiety is defined as a transitory state
of anxiety associated with separation events experiences
by a mother about leaving her baby (Hock, 1984). This
study will investigate the relationship between maternal
separation anxiety (as measured by Hock's scale, 1984)
and a mother's history of separation and her separation
anxiety responses (as measured by Hansburg's Separation
Anxiety Test, 1980). The research questions are: Do
mothers who experience more separations and losses in
childhood and adolescence express higher levels of
separation anxiety in general and stronger maternal
separation anxiety in particular? Will separation anxiety
responses from married mothers be different from the
divorced mothers? Does the quality of the marital
relationship contribute to the mothers' separation anxiety?
A total of 80 middle-class mothers of young
children will be recruited in Mexico City. Forty of those
mothers will be married and 40 will be divorced. All of
the mothers will participate on a voluntary basis and
questionnaires will only be identified by an ID number,
making all responses anonymous.
Results from this study can support the
hypothesis that significant early separation experiences
influence separation anxiety feelings that a mother reports
in response to separation situations in general, and to the
prospect of leaving her child specifically. The
contribution that a supportive husband has on the mother's
feelings of separation anxiety will also be addressed.
11.4
Parent-Child Attachment Dimensions
in Middle Childhood
Kathryn A. Kerns, Patricia L. Tomich,
Jeffrey E. Aspelmeier and Chandra M. Graybill
Kent State University
There has been very little work on attachment in middle
childhood, despite the fact that children cite parents as the
primary providers of social and emotional support during
this age period. Two measures of parent-child attachment
were evaluated: the Security Scale, which assesses
attachment on a security-insecurity dimension, and the
Attachment Strategies Questionnaire, which assesses
Avoidant and Preoccupied coping with a particular
attachment figure. Third and sixth grade children reported
their relationships with mothers and fathers. Evidence of
convergent validity was obtained. There were also age
differences for some of the attachment dimensions.
11.5
Mothers' Perceptions of Childbirth and the Mother-
Infant Relationship: Relations With Internal Working
Models of Attachment
Leah Sweeden, Nancy Hazen, and Deborah Jacobvitz
University of Texas
The primary purpose of this study is to examine the links
between mothers' working models of attachment, their
perceptions of childbirth, and their subsequent caregiving
patterns. 120 first- time mothers participated in the study.
Mothers' working models of attachment were assessed
using the Adult Attachment Interview. Postnatally, their
perceptions of their childbirth experiences were assessed
using a telephone interview, and their caregiving quality
was assessed using videotaped observations of their
interactions with their 8-month-olds in play, feeding, and
dressing. Results indicated that secure versus insecure
attachment interacted with mothers' perception of their
childbirth experiences to predict quality of caregiving.
Specifically, for insecure mothers, perception of a difficult
childbirth experience was related to less accepting and
sensitive interaction with their infants, whereas secure
mothers were more accepting and sensitive in relation to
the perceived difficulty of their childbirth. In addition,
mothers who reported unresolved loss of attachment
figures or childhood abuse or trauma were more likely
than other mothers to report that they received less support
during childbirth, and to report post-partum depression;
and reported post-partum depression was related to poorer
quality of care. Thus, the results of this study suggest that
a difficult childbirth experience may be a risk factor for
insecure mothers, hampering their ability to provide
sensitive care.
Relation Between Attachment Styles and Other
Individual Difference Variables
11.6
Sex, Gender Roles, and Attachment Patterns
in Young Adults
Shawnda Servello and Kim Bartholomew
Simon Fraser University
Some adult attachment research has found relatively more
preoccupied women and dismissing men; similarly, studies
of gender roles have found relatively more feminine
women and masculine men. Additionally, both
preoccupied and feminine women and dismissing and
masculine men report low satisfaction in their romantic
relationships. Building on these parallels, the present
study examined whether sex differences in attachment
patterns could be explained by sex differences in gender
roles. Using a college sample, the expected sex
differences in attachment and gender roles were
confirmed. The hypotheses were supported for women but
not men. These findings substantiate the link between
gender roles and attachment patterns, but suggest that
other factors will be important in explaining sex
differences in adult attachment.
11.7
The Relationship of Gender and Developmental Stage
To Adult Attachment Styles: A Twin Study
Mariana Brussoni, Tannis M. MacBeth,
Kerry L. Jang, Megan Clark, W. John Livesley
University of British Columbia
A minimum of 207 twin pairs (approximately 50%
monozygotic) aged 16 to 67 years completed the
Relationship Questionnaire (RQ) and the Relationship
Scales Questionnaire (RSQ). Data analyses explore both
gender differences and developmental trends, focusing on
the following questions. If gender differences are found,
are they related more strongly to genetic or environmental
factors? If no gender differences are found, is the
similarity predominantly genetic or environmental? Do
genetic factors and shared and non- shared environmental
factors relate similarly or differently to adult attachment
styles at different points in development?
11.8
Affect Regulation Through Sensation Seeking
Behavior: An Adult Attachment Perspective
Katherine B. Carnelley,
University of Wales College of Cardiff
Janet B. Ruscher, Tulane University
Kate H. Roberts,
University of Wales College of Cardiff
The attachment and exploratory systems are
complimentary such that a secure base enables one to
explore the environment. An adult manifestation of
exploration might be sensation seeking. Previous research
indicates that avoidant infants and adults tend to explore
rather than pursue intimacy. Thus avoidance, but not
preoccupation, should be associated with engagement in
sensation seeking. The present study confirmed this
prediction and addressed whether sensation seeking served
an affect regulatory function. Consistent with predictions
about affect regulation, avoidant respondents generally
indicated that sensation seeking would produce positive
outcomes. In addition, preoccupied respondents expected
positive affect when sensation seeking potentially
enhanced intimacy.
11.9
Attachment Styles and Relationship Orientations
Erik Jacobson and Margaret S. Clark
Carnegie Mellon University
Adopting a Communal Orientation involves responding to
the other's needs and expecting the other to respond to
one's own needs. It requires trusting others and valuing
oneself. We predicted (and found) Communal Orientation
to be positively related to Secure attachment, unrelated
Anxious/Ambivalent attachment and negatively related to
Avoidant attachment. Adopting an Exchange Orientation
involves benefiting the other in response to benefits
received or expected from the other. It requires neither
little trust in others nor assumptions of one's own value.
We predicted (and found) Exchange Orientation to be
positively related to having an Anxious/Ambivalent or
Avoidant attachment style and unrelated to having a
Secure attachment style.
11.10
Secure and Insecure Thinking:
The Relationship of Cognitive Complexity to
Attachment Style
Harry Weger Jr. and Leah E. Polcar
University of Arizona
The purpose of this investigation is to uncover cognitive
processes underlying adult attachment style. While
several studies have examined the relationship of adult
attachment to communication and relational outcomes,
little work has been undertaken to uncover the mental
processes underlying attachment style. The position of
this paper is that one dimension underlying adult
attachment is cognitive complexity. A pilot study found
that measures of secure and insecure attachment are
positively related to cognitive complexity. This paper is an
extension of that study and includes measures of
interpersonal complexity, relational complexity,
comforting behavior, and continuous as well as categorical
measures of attachment.
11.11
Personality Characteristics of
Prototypic Attachment Categories
Elaine Scharfe
Simon Fraser University
In this paper, I examined the perceived personality traits
associated with Bartholomew's four category model of
adult attachment. I asked participants to either generate
personality traits or rate the magnitude of personality traits
for each of the four prototypes. Preliminary results
suggest that perceptions of personality associated with
each attachment category are consistent with findings
indicating an association between individual differences in
attachment and personality (e.g., Brennan & Shaver,
1993). Results suggest that internal working models are
not simply an internal representation that guide
interpretation, but may also include expectations of
behaviour from different types of people.
11.12
Attachment and Emotional Intelligence
Youngmee Kim
University of Rochester
The relationship between attachment styles and emotional
intelligence was tested. Two models of attachment styles
(e.g., three- or four-category models) were compared and
revealed that secure people were more attentive to their
emotions, and recovered positive mood more than insecure
people. Women were found to be more attentive to their
emotions than men, and secure women recovered positive
mood more than secure men. Implications for gender
differences in emotional intelligence and attachment are
discussed.
Relation Between Negative Life Experiences
and Attachment
11.13
The Relationship Between Adult Attachment Style and
Physical Aggression and Psychological Abuse in
Heterosexual Dating Relationships
Joanne M. Shovlin,
Virginia Consortium for Professional Psychology
Barbara A. Winstead and Robin J. Lewis,
Old Dominion University
The study investigated attachment style (as conceptualized
by Bartholomew) in a current relationship and physical
and emotional abuse. Attachment style did not predict
physical or verbal aggression. Women were more likely
than men to report being physically aggressive toward
their partners. Attachment style was related to other
relationship measures. Individuals with Anxious
attachment reported more emotional abuse and
possessiveness. Avoidant individuals reported higher
levels of perceived risk in intimacy. Relationship quality
was higher for Secures than for any other groups. Length
of relationship was positively related to verbal aggression
and emotional abuse. The results suggest that attachment
in relationships is a better predictor of psychological
qualities of relationships than aggressive incidents in
relationships.
11.14
How Do Women Leave? The Reciprocal Relationship
Between Abuse and Attachment Security
Antonia J. Z. Henderson
Simon Fraser University
The question of why women stay with, and return to,
partners who abuse them continues to be an enigma to
clinicians and researchers. Following up on earlier work
examining the attachment patterns of women having
recently left an abusive partner, I interviewed a select
subsample in order to better understand the process of
separation from a long term abusive relationship. Core
themes from interviews suggest that women+s ability to
remain out of abusive relationships may be mediated by
attachment security, and that attachment security may be
mediated by experiences of abuse. This exploratory
analysis suggests that future research should look at the
reciprocal dynamic between abuse and internal
representations of self and other.
11.15
The Relationship Between Traumatic Childhood
Experiences and Adult Attachment Styles
Megan D. Clark, Tannis M MacBeth,
Kerry L. Jang, Mariana Brussoni,
and W. John Livesley, University of British Columbia
Previous research indicated that negative childhood
experiences are associated with higher rates of insecure
adult attachment (Brennan, Shaver, & Tobey, 1991;
Alexander, 1993). This study focuses on the relationship
between childhood traumatic experiences and adult
attachment. Adult Twins (207 pairs) completed
Bartholomew's self- report attachment measures, the
Relationship Questionnaire (RQ) and The Relationship
Scales Questionnaire (RSQ) (Griffin & Bartholomew,
1994), an Events Questionnaire measuring retrospective
reports of traumatic events, and the symptoms check list
(SCL-90-R). We will examine the associations among
reported childhood traumatic events, adult attachment, and
symptoms experienced. The twin data will allow us to
explore the relative contributions of genetics and
environment.
11.16
Attachment Representations, Childhood Rejection,
and Loneliness
Rebecca Cobb and Kim Bartholomew
Simon Fraser University
We examined the relative contributions of childhood
experiences and current attachment representations to
adult loneliness. Results indicated that the relationship
between parental rejection in childhood and current
loneliness is mediated by current attachment patterns.
However, peer rejection in childhood predicts loneliness in
adulthood, independently of current attachment. We
speculate that attachment insecurity contributes to
emotional loneliness, while peer rejection influences
social loneliness. These results highlight the importance
of both childhood parental and peer relationships as
antecedents of adult loneliness.
11.17
The Influence of Working Models of Attachment and
Feelings of Stigma on Adjustment to Illness
Wartini Pramana and Judith Feeney
The University of Queensland
The present study examined the role of working models of
attachment and feelings of stigma in predicting adjustment
to illness (illness behaviours and coping effectiveness) in
asthma sufferers. Supporting the proposed model,
negative models of self emerged as a significant predictor
of feelings of stigma. Positive models of others directly
predicted higher levels of social illness behaviours and
fewer disability days. Furthermore, coping effectiveness,
health care utilisation, social and work illness behaviours
were predicted indirectly (though weakly) by working
models of self, mediated by feelings of stigma. However,
the number of days of experiencing asthma symptoms
were not predicted by any of the independent variables.
11.18
Attachment, Grief and Coping:
An Integrated Model of Parental Bereavement
Vincent J. Conway
University of Queensland
A model of parental bereavement was developed,
integrating theories of attachment, grief and coping. To
test this model, 45 subjects who had experienced the
death of a child completed questionnaire measures of
relevant variables. Attachment style was measured using a
multiple-item questionnaire yielding scores on five scales,
including Anxiety about relationships and Discomfort
with closeness. Coping strategies were assessed using a
modified version of the Ways of Coping Checklist
(Folkman & Lazarus, 1980), and multiple dimensions of
grief were measured using a questionnaire based on
attachment theory (Jacobs, Kosten, Kasl, Ostfeld,
Berkman & Charpentier, 1987-88). Attachment style
mediated the effects of grief and coping on current anxiety
and depression, which were both positively associated
with Anxiety about relationships. The association
between Discomfort with closeness and current anxiety
was marginally significant.
11.19
Adolescent Romantic Relationship Loss
and Adult Attachment
Aine M. Humble, Mount Saint Vincent University
Berna J. Skrypnek, University of Alberta
To investigate the relationship between adolescent
relationship experiences and adult attachment styles, 386
young adults completed measures of adolescent and adult
attachment (dismissing, preoccupied, fearful, and secure),
emotional distress, and relationship history. A strong
relationship was found between adolescent attachment
styles and (1) levels of emotional distress following
adolescent romantic relationship breakup, and (2)
perceptions of who ended the meaningful adolescent
relationship. We also found a relationship between levels
of emotional distress over adolescent relationship breakup
and current attachment styles. Implications of adolescent
relationship experiences (particularly relationship loss) in
contributing to secure versus insecure attachment styles in
adults are discussed.
11.20
Unrequited Love: Everything Ventured,
Nothing Gained?
Briony K. Hollick and C.A. Elizabeth Brimacombe
University of Victoria
We investigated the relationship between attachment
styles and unrequited love experiences. A preliminary
study involving 180 participants found that, after recalling
an unrequited love experience, rejectors and would-be
lovers felt differently about a number of dimensions, such
as guilt and self-esteem. The experience was generally
more negative for rejectors than would-be lovers. In
addition, the secure, avoidant, and anxious/ambivalent
attachment styles experienced unrequited love in different
ways. "Secure" individuals reported fewer negative
feelings than either "avoidant" or "anxious/ambivalent"
individuals. In a follow-up investigation, these factors, as
well as age and gender differences, are explored.
Friendship -- Conflict and Dissolution
11.21
Letting Others Out of Hot Water:
Forgiveness in Social Predicaments
Holley S. Hodgins and Elizabeth A. Liebeskind
Skidmore College
Subjects imagined themselves victims after face-
threatening predicaments, received accounts, and wrote
responses. Type of account (refusals, excuses, and
concessions), closeness and status were manipulated.
Responses were coded and subjects predicted future
relationships. Findings showed that higher responsibility
resulted in more positive and fewer negative comments, a
more positive overall tone, and better future outcome.
Effects were especially pronounced for friends. Results
suggest that friends are forgiven more than acquaintances
when they take responsibility but are forgiven less if they
fail to apologize.
11.22
Competition in a Structured Play Situation in Relation
to the Continuation of Children's Friendships
Franca Tani, Barry Schneider, Ada Fonzi,
and Giovanna Tomada, University of Pisa
Our study was undertaken in order to determine whether
children's behavior in a structured competitive game
situation would predict their concurrent friendship status
as well as the continuation of their friendship. This
hypothesis was tested using a car-race task developed for
this research program with eight-year olds. Friends were
more likely to engage in conflict while respecting the
rules, whereas non-friends were more likely to avoid
conflict in ways that violated the rules. As well, the affect
displayed by friends while playing was significantly more
likely to be positive. In contrast, there was scant support
for our hypothesis that those qualities would be associated
with the continuation of friendship.
11.23
Children's Negotiation Behavior
as a Predictor of the Continuation of Their Friendships
Ada Fonzi, Giovanna Tomada, Barry Schneider and
Franca Tani, University of Florence
We hypothesized that friends would be more adept in their
negotiations than non-friends regarding the sharing of an
object and that this ability would predict the continuation
of their friendship. Friendship nomination procedures and
sociometric choice nominations were administered to 400
Grade 3 pupils of sexes. We asked the subjects to decide
how they would share a single Kinder-Surprise (a
chocolate egg with a toy inside). There were some
indications that the ability to negotiate the sharing of an
object emerged as a salient predictor of the continuation of
children's friendships. Youngsters whose friendships were
to continue tended to negotiate rather than to accept their
partners' initial proposal, but to be more sensitive and
creative in their later propositions.
Violence and Abuse in Close Relationships
11.24
On-line Thoughts About Marital Interaction Within
Distressed, Nondistressed and Aggressive Couples
Timothy Dun and Alan Sillars, University of Montana
Linda Roberts, University of Wisconsin
Kenneth Leonard, Research Institute on Addictions,
Buffalo, New York
The present study compares the thoughts and feelings of
physically aggressive and nonaggressive spouses during a
discussion of marital conflicts. 150 couples engaged in a
naturalistic conflict discussion and individually reported
thoughts and feelings while viewing videotapes of the
discussion. Additionally, husbands received alcohol, a
placebo, or no alcohol before engaging in the discussion.
Three features of the video-assisted recall data are given
particularly attention in this analysis: (a) reports of
emotional experience, especially the frequency of angry
emotions and spontaneous explanations for anger; (b)
relative attention to content versus process issues in the
discussions; and (c) the complexity of inferences about the
partner's perspective.
11.25
What's Love Got To Do With It:
Assessing Dysfunctional Love Beliefs
in Domestically Violent Men
Erin Hardin, Carl A. Ridley,
Hobart H. Cleveland and Clyde M. Feldman
The University of Arizona
The purpose of this study was to examine the role of
dysfunctional love beliefs in domestically violent behavior.
Data were collected from 115 Korean men currently in
significant heterosexual relationships between the ages of
20-35. Hierarchical discriminant analyses were used.
Analyses indicate that a significant relationship exists
between dysfunctional love beliefs and the levels of abuse,
discriminating physically abusive, psychologically abusive,
and nonabusive men. Subscales of "jealousy" and
"overdependency" as indicators of love were also found to
be significant discriminators between the three levels of
abusive men. Relationship specific love beliefs were found
to be a better predictor of domestic violence than general
love beliefs.
11.26
Relational Qualities and Beliefs Among
Abusive Men in Korea
Carl A. Ridley, Erin Hardin,
Hobart H. Cleveland, and Clyde M. Feldman
The University of Arizona
The purpose of this study was to distinguish Korean men
involved in different levels and intensities of abusive
relationships according to relational characteristics
including relational power, relational closeness, relational
satisfaction, dysfunctional relationship beliefs,
interpersonal self-perception, and relationship acceptance.
A total of 115 Korean men in significant heterosexual
relationships between the ages of 20-35 were selected for
participation. Analyses indicate that relational power
imbalances, as well as attitudes about relational power,
were the most significant factors in distinguishing men in
different groups. Discussion provides possible
explanations for the centrality of power in domestic
violence.
11.27
The Association Between the Abusive Personality
and Gay Male Intimate Abuse
Monica A. Landolt and Donald G. Dutton
University of British Columbia
Past research has implicated the Abusive Personality as a
key factor in heterosexual domestic violence (Dutton &
Starzomski, 1993; Dutton, 1994). In the present study, 52
gay male couples completed questionnaires including two
measures of abuse and four measures which together
constitute the Abusive Personality. Results indicate that
intimate abuse and the Abusive Personality were clearly
associated, suggesting that this explanatory model of abuse
developed in heterosexual relationships does have
relevance in the gay male case and should be used as a
starting point for further investigations.
11.28
Characteristics of Urban Domestic Violence Survivors:
Implications for Program Planning
Andrea J. Martin, Melissa M. Lin
Urban Women's Retreat, New York
Robert E. Sage, Urban Resource Institute, Brooklyn
Lorraine Madry, Urban Women's Retreat, New York
and Beny J. Primm
Urban Resource Institute, Brooklyn
Women living in an urban domestic violence shelter (N =
80) were interviewed to assess their background
characteristics and to offer recommendations for program
planning. Residents interviewed were largely African-
American (43.8%) or Latina (47.5%) women with
children. The majority of residents suffered long term
abuse and 30% of them attempted suicide at least one time
in their lives. High levels of alcohol and drug usage were
reported for the batterers and in the women's families and
the batterers' families. Despite increasing awareness of
domestic violence, younger residents suffered from more
depression and were more likely to attempt suicide.
11.29
Relating Control, Self-esteem, Psychological and
Physical Health Symptoms
in Physically Revictimized Individuals
Jocelyn B. Proulx
University of Manitoba
The purpose of this study was to examine the relationship
between anxiety and general health and control and self-
esteem in individuals physically abused in childhood and
revictimized in physically violent dating relationships and
non-victimized individuals. Analysis of variance revealed
that revictimized individuals reported more anxiety,
somatization and general health symptoms, and lower self-
esteem and more external locus of control than
nonvictimized individuals. Further, locus of control and
self-esteem were more predictive of distress symptoms in
the revictimized group, possibly identifying them as
mediators of distress and variables worthy of research and
therapeutic consideration.
11.30
The Prediction of Sexually Coercive Behaviors Among
Korean Males
Hobart H. Cleveland, Erin Hardin,
Carl Ridley and Clyde M. Feldman
University of Arizona
The purpose of this study was to explore the prediction of
sexually coercive behaviors in a data set of Korean men
collected to address the related issue of domestic abuse.
Predictors from both the individual level, (self-concept)
and relational level (relationship satisfaction and
relationship behaviors) were examined. A total of 115
Korean men in significant heterosexual relationships
between the ages of 20-35 were selected for participation.
Analyses indicate that by selected predictors from both the
individual level and the relational level fifty percent of the
variance in sexually coercive behaviors can be explained.
Of particular interest is the significance of the interaction
between self-concept, an individual level variable, and
abusive psychological behaviors within the relationship, a
relational variable.
11.31
All in the Family:
A Longitudinal Study of Incestuous Relationships
Catherine Cameron
University of La Verne
A longitudinal study of 72 female therapy clients yielded
information about incestuous parent-child relationships.
The women's conscious memory of sexual abuse and
ranged from (prior) amnesia to continuous recall. Data
were gathered on their family of origin, their abuse,
consequences over time, memories faced in adulthood, the
therapeutic experience, and personal changes during the
decade of research (1986-1995). Results showed that
women who had (formerly) been amnesic to sexual abuse
were significantly more likely to have experienced parent-
child incest, severe sexual abuse, and crisis on recall.
Serious personal, family, and societal implications of these
findings are proposed.
Mark Baldwin - <baldwin@uwinnipeg.ca>,
Alison Wiigs - <wiigs@ucalgary.ca>